Video Explaining HttpPost in Tally Prime (HTTP JSON)

Very nice but Share the code on post or mail me on rohit_khedar@yahoo.co.in

 

I think reverse engineering is not very allowed practice So, sir samhaal ke hi use karna

 

Not get it properly please explain
Is there any risk?

 

Basically You are using GST API without their consent.

Waise toh sayad hi kuch hoga but feer bhi. Companies utna dhyaan nahi deti in chizo par

 

But I am not using their any GST API
This is only the automate process by using python and tdl as we serch taxpayer details in gst portal manually by using gstin and captcha(absolutely free of cost)
Those process Devendra Ji implement in tally by tdl using http request
similarly I have done this
Please expert give your valuable remarks about this matter
is this wrong if we using gst portal to serch gstin in this way?

 

Amit Ji and Devendra Ji please share you thought in this matter

 

If Govt. it self provide plate form on GST portal to verify the GST number authenticate or not & its return status Regulars or not and that information you incorporate thru GST portal to tally i think its not break any low or rule.

i am interested to buy it. If possible then ping me on my what's up number 9826026109.

Mani

 

Thanks for your reply sir.
But sorry I made this tdl for only use for my company it is not for sale.
Actually I am not even sale any of my tdl to anybody just made for personal use
it is my passion to make tdl

 

Thanks Amit ji for your valuable feedback

 

What you are doing(most people doing) is called web scraping,
it is illegal unless authorized by website.
If you see Goods & Services Tax (GST) | Website Policies, it prohibits web scraping - So it's Illegal to do so

In general, I don't think they will take any legal action against this unless you spam or effect their servers.

If you want to go legal way, use paid APIs by GSP's

 

Thanks Mr. Vineeth for your valuable reply.I am already using paid API
It was done only for testing purpose

 

In the starting of the gst we do the same automation for our other personal erp , then rule came that porbithed of automation on gst.gov.in so we stopped it. So want to tell not allowed ethically.

 

Okay

 

As long as you are using your GST login and password to access your own GST Data, by whatever means.. Its not illegal.

What you are doing is not web scrapping at all and doesn't come under any other activity specifically prohibited by GST Portal Website Policy

I assume that Python script is only used to covert captcha from png format to jpeg format ( Am I Right ?)


ICAI has provided SPEQTA GST (software) to practicing CAs , which accesses GST data using GST Portal login and password..

If you use Tally for that purpose, I don't see any legal issue.

Be Brave ... be strong.. ask yourself, "Am I doing wrong?"

Listen to the reply from your Heart ❤️ and act accordingly .

 

that's not true.

Even if you use your login password and access your data also web scraping is web scraping and it's not legal unless authorized by website.

If this not web scraping what is web scraping for you?

SPEQTA GST (software) or any software that access GST data and file returns uses GST API by GSP providers.
GST Developer Portal | Home

 

Web scraping is the process of collecting unstructured and structured data in an automated manner.

We are not using any automation on GST portal, Automation is done on Tally not GST Portal, In this TDL we go to url, provide our gstin number , provide password and then enter captcha wherever required. and then the information which displayed is used by us for automation at our end in Tally.

we are not crawling through GST Portal and collecting every possible data, we are accessing data which is available to us using our login id and password.

 

So this post has become controversial

My Motive was to explain HTTP JSON , POST method .. well others saw some opportunity in it ..Enjoy

 

Yes, I think it started with me... BTW I also think It isn't web scraping exactly but Still it's not something illegal rather It should be done by the Permission of GST People.

Why Am I saying this?
Because One of my known was using WhatsApp APIs without their consent and later he recieved a notice from WhatsApp.

Btw don't worry gst Wale 99% kuch nahi bolenge... Company generally don't do this but yes then can anytime block you.

 

Because at the end of the day...it's their APIs and they make the rules.

 

अरे कितना डराओगे, बच्चे की जान लोगे क्या

 

Thanks for your brilliant idea to get GST data through Tally itself. I also want to do it myself to get PAN data from IRD (Nepal) and write a TDL file as per your explanation in the video, but I can't. Please share your email address with me at gsu143@gmail.com, I want to share my project with you for proper guidance, and I only play with TDL for educational purposes; I've never engaged in commercial transactions with it. Thank you, once again.

Thanks for your brilliant idea to get GST data through Tally itself. I also want to do it myself to get PAN data from IRD (Nepal) and write a TDL file as per your explanation in the video, but I can't. Please share your email address with me at gsu143@gmail.com, I want to share my project with you for proper guidance, and I only play with TDL for educational purposes; I've never engaged in commercial transactions with it. Thank you, once again.